Types of Compost Bins: Trash to Treasure

  • By: Sam Richards
  • Date: August 31, 2023
  • Time to read: 8 min.

In today’s environmentally-conscious era, composting emerges as one of the most effective and sustainable methods of recycling organic waste. At its core, composting is the biological decomposition of organic materials by microorganisms under controlled conditions to produce a humus-like end product. This rich, dark, crumbly substance not only enhances the fertility and structure of the soil in gardens but also significantly reduces the amount of waste funneled into landfills, thereby mitigating methane emissions. As composting gains popularity among gardeners and eco-enthusiasts alike, the need for the right equipment becomes paramount. One primary component of the composting process is the bin in which decomposition takes place. With numerous types and styles available in the market, making an informed choice can be overwhelming. This article endeavors to simplify that choice by delving deep into the different types of compost bins, exploring their advantages, drawbacks, and ideal use cases, to guide you in finding the perfect fit for your composting needs.

Tumbler Compost Bins

Tumbler compost bins, a modern twist to traditional composting methods, are characterized by their cylindrical design and ability to rotate. Mounted on a stand or frame, these bins can be turned, either by hand or using a crank, to mix and aerate the composting materials inside.

  • Design and Functionality:
    • Composed typically of durable plastic or metal, these tumblers often feature dark colors to absorb heat, thereby accelerating the composting process.
    • The rotation mechanism aids in providing consistent aeration, which not only speeds up the decomposition process but also discourages the growth of anaerobic bacteria that can cause unpleasant odors.
    • Some models come with dual chambers, allowing users to fill one side while the other side is still decomposing, ensuring a continuous supply of fresh compost.
  • Benefits:
    • Speedy Decomposition: Due to regular aeration and heat absorption, compost can be ready in as little as a few weeks under optimal conditions.
    • Pest Resistance: Being elevated off the ground, tumbler bins minimize the risk of rodent infestations, a common concern with ground-level bins.
    • User-Friendly: The turning mechanism eliminates the need for manually turning the pile with a pitchfork or shovel.
  • Drawbacks:
    • Cost: Tumblers are generally more expensive upfront than stationary bins or DIY options.
    • Volume Limitations: Due to their design, tumblers might not be the best fit for those looking to compost large amounts of waste at once.
    • Moisture Regulation: Without proper care, tumblers can become too wet or too dry, affecting the composting process.

In essence, tumbler compost bins are an excellent choice for those who want a clean, efficient, and relatively quick composting solution, especially in suburban settings where space might be limited and aesthetics a consideration.

Stationary Outdoor Bins

Stationary outdoor compost bins, the stalwarts of backyard composting, are fixed structures that stand in a designated spot in your garden or yard. Often they are the first image that comes to mind when one thinks of composting.

  • Design and Functionality:
    • Typically crafted from wood, plastic, or wire mesh, these bins have an open bottom, allowing them to sit directly on the soil. This direct contact encourages worms and beneficial microbes to move freely between the compost and the soil.
    • They feature a lid or cover to retain moisture and keep out larger pests, while side vents promote aeration. Some designs even include removable panels or doors at the base for easy extraction of the finished compost.
    • Over time, layers of organic material, such as leaves, grass clippings, and kitchen scraps, are added, creating a ‘compost lasagna’ that decomposes from the bottom up.
  • Benefits:
    • Large Capacity: Due to their stationary nature, these bins can accommodate larger volumes of waste, making them ideal for households with sizable yards or gardens.
    • Passive Decomposition: With minimal intervention, nature does most of the work. The heat generated within the pile combined with the actions of worms and microbes ensures effective breakdown.
    • Economical: These bins tend to be less costly than tumbler varieties and can also be DIY-ed with readily available materials.
  • Drawbacks:
    • Slower Decomposition: Without active turning or aeration, the composting process in stationary bins can be more prolonged compared to tumblers.
    • Potential for Pests: The ground contact, while beneficial for microbial activity, can also attract unwanted guests like rodents if not properly managed.
    • Manual Labor: Harvesting finished compost, usually from the bottom, can be more labor-intensive and messy.

In summary, stationary outdoor bins are a classic, cost-effective solution for avid gardeners and those with ample outdoor space. They may require a bit more patience and occasional maintenance, but the reward is a substantial yield of rich, crumbly compost ready to nourish the garden.

Worm Composting Bins (Vermicomposting)

Vermicomposting is a unique and highly efficient form of composting that harnesses the natural appetite and digestion process of worms, particularly red wigglers, to break down organic waste. These bins are specifically designed to create an optimal environment for these wriggly decomposers.

  • Design and Functionality:
    • Most worm bins consist of multiple stacking trays with perforations. As worms finish composting the bottom tray, they move upwards to access fresh organic material, leaving behind rich worm castings.
    • The base often features a collection tray or spout, making it easy to harvest the highly nutrient-dense “worm tea” or leachate, an excellent liquid fertilizer.
    • The design promotes aeration, moisture retention, and easy access to feed and harvest without disturbing the worms too much.
  • Benefits:
    • Nutrient-Rich Byproducts: Vermicomposting not only produces worm castings, an exceptional soil amendment but also worm tea, both of which are highly beneficial for plants.
    • Indoor and Outdoor Flexibility: These bins can be kept indoors, like in a basement or garage, or outside, making vermicomposting possible even for those without a yard.
    • Odorless Process: When managed correctly, worm composting is a virtually odorless process, a significant advantage for indoor setups.
    • Efficient Breakdown: Worms can process their body weight in food daily, leading to a relatively quick breakdown of organic materials.
  • Drawbacks:
    • Selective Diet: Worms are choosy eaters. They prefer vegetable scraps and avoid certain materials like meat, dairy, and oily foods. A wrong mix can harm the worms and slow down the process.
    • Temperature Sensitivity: Red wigglers thrive in specific temperature ranges. Extreme cold or heat can be detrimental to their health, demanding close attention in fluctuating climates.
    • Initial Setup: Acquiring the right species of worms and setting up the bin for the first time might require a bit of research and effort.

In a nutshell, vermicomposting offers an eco-friendly solution, especially for urban dwellers or those with limited outdoor space. While it requires an understanding of the worms’ needs, the nutrient-packed output and efficiency of the process make it a favorite choice for many organic gardening enthusiasts.

Cone-Shaped Compost Bins

These bins are conically shaped, wider at the bottom, and tapering to the top.

  • Benefits:
    • Efficient aeration which speeds up decomposition
    • Easy to set up and requires minimal maintenance
  • Drawbacks:
    • Compost can be difficult to turn
    • Potential to attract pests if not well-maintained

Kitchen Compost Bins
Designed for indoor use, these bins are perfect for daily kitchen waste.

  • Benefits:
    • Convenient for collecting daily kitchen scraps
    • Often designed with odor control features
  • Drawbacks:
    • Limited capacity
    • Requires regular emptying to avoid odors

Continuous Composters

Continuous composting, as the name suggests, is a method that allows for the ongoing addition and extraction of compost without waiting for an entire batch to complete. Continuous composters are designed to accommodate this running cycle, making it an ongoing, dynamic process.

  • Design and Functionality:
    • Continuous composters often resemble vertical columns or towers. They’re structured so that fresh organic material is added to the top while mature compost is extracted from the bottom.
    • They incorporate aeration mechanisms throughout, ensuring that oxygen reaches all layers, vital for the aerobic decomposition process.
    • Some designs may feature multiple compartments or shelves within, allowing for easy segregation of materials based on their decomposition stage.
    • Given their vertical orientation, they maximize the composting potential of a small footprint, making them space-efficient.
  • Benefits:
    • Steady Supply: Since there’s no need to wait for an entire batch to finish, users get a steady supply of compost as the bottom layers mature while fresh waste is added to the top.
    • Space Efficiency: Their vertical design ensures that they occupy minimal ground space, making them suitable for smaller gardens or patios.
    • User-Friendly: The continuous input-output system means there’s less need for turning or mixing. Mature compost can be easily extracted from the base.
  • Drawbacks:
    • Monitoring Challenges: Given that different stages of compost coexist within the bin, monitoring moisture levels and decomposition consistency might be slightly challenging.
    • Potential Overloading: The ease of continuous addition can sometimes lead to overloading, where fresh waste is added faster than the bottom layers can decompose.
    • Aesthetic Considerations: Their tall and columnar design might not appeal to everyone and could stand out in some garden settings.

To sum it up, continuous composters offer an uninterrupted composting solution ideal for those who generate organic waste regularly and prefer a constant supply of compost. They’re particularly beneficial for urban gardeners or those with limited space. However, success with this system requires a balanced approach to adding fresh material and regularly harvesting the finished compost.

Pallet Compost Bins

Made from repurposed wooden pallets, these bins are an eco-friendly choice.

  • Benefits:
    • Inexpensive and easy to set up
    • Provides good aeration for compost
  • Drawbacks:
    • Not always aesthetically pleasing
    • Potential for pests due to the gaps between pallets


The world of composting, rich in its diversity, offers a plethora of options to cater to varying needs, preferences, and environments. From the innovative rotations of tumbler compost bins to the ecological dance of worms in vermicomposting, and the space-saving efficiency of continuous composters, the choices available to the eco-conscious individual have never been more extensive.

Selecting the right compost bin isn’t just about aesthetic appeal or capacity; it’s about aligning with your lifestyle, the volume of waste you generate, the space available, and the level of involvement you wish to have in the composting process. While a stationary outdoor bin might suit those with larger gardens and a more hands-off approach, an urban dweller might find solace in the compactness of a kitchen compost bin or the efficiency of worm composting.

Moreover, it’s vital to remember that composting isn’t merely a process of waste reduction. It’s a commitment to a more sustainable lifestyle, a step towards reducing our carbon footprint, and an investment in the health of our gardens and, by extension, our planet. As you venture into composting or perhaps refine your existing setup, take pride in knowing that your efforts contribute directly to a greener, more sustainable future. Armed with knowledge and insights from this article, we hope you feel empowered to make an informed decision, ensuring that your composting journey is both fruitful and fulfilling. Remember, every bit of composted waste is a step away from landfills and a stride towards a more nourished Earth. Happy composting!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.