How to Turn Compost (Things You Need to Know)

  • By: Sam Richards
  • Date: September 8, 2023
  • Time to read: 9 min.

Composting, often dubbed as nature’s way of recycling, is a practice that dates back thousands of years. By transforming organic waste materials into nutrient-rich compost, we not only reduce the strain on landfills but also gift our gardens with a natural fertilizer. This symbiotic relationship between humans, waste, and the earth underscores the essence of sustainability. However, creating high-quality compost isn’t as simple as merely stacking organic matter and waiting. One of the pivotal steps to achieving effective composting is turning the pile, an action that many novice gardeners might overlook. This guide aims to shed light on the importance of turning compost, offering insights into the why, when, and how to ensure that your composting efforts bear fruit—or more accurately, fertile soil. Dive in to discover the secrets of turning compost and nurturing a thriving garden.

Understanding Why We Turn Compost

Composting is not just about letting organic materials decompose on their own; it’s a process that thrives on balance and active involvement. Turning compost, or aerating it, is a primary activity that’s as much about science as it is about practical gardening. Let’s delve deeper into the reasons:

  • Aeration and Microbial Activity: Think of your compost pile as a living entity teeming with microorganisms. These tiny powerhouses are responsible for breaking down organic material. However, for them to function efficiently, they need oxygen. Turning compost introduces air, which prevents the pile from becoming anaerobic (devoid of oxygen) and compacted. Anaerobic conditions can lead to a slowed decomposition process and the production of less desirable byproducts, such as methane.
  • Faster Decomposition: The action of turning stirs up the compost, which in turn distributes heat generated by microbial activity. This heat is a sign of active decomposition. By spreading it throughout the pile, you ensure that organic materials break down more uniformly and swiftly.
  • Homogeneous Decomposition: The goal is to have a compost pile that decomposes evenly, leaving no chunky or undecomposed materials. Turning ensures that all parts, especially the often neglected middle sections, get their turn on the outside, exposed to different microbial communities and environmental factors.
  • Preventing Odor and Pests: A stagnant, compacted compost pile can start producing a foul odor, a signal that it might be going anaerobic. These smells can attract pests, from tiny gnats to larger critters. Regular turning keeps the compost smelling earthy and deters unwelcome guests.

By understanding these nuances, it becomes clear that turning compost is not just a task to tick off but an essential step in nurturing a successful, flourishing compost pile.

When to Turn Your Compost

Knowing why to turn compost is half the battle; understanding when to do so completes the equation. Timing can have a significant influence on the efficiency of the composting process, impacting decomposition rates and the final quality of the compost. Let’s explore the intricate timings and signs that dictate when your compost pile needs a good stir:

  • Observational Signs: Over time, as you familiarize yourself with your compost pile, you’ll begin to notice certain cues that suggest it’s time to turn:
    • Matted Layers: These are layers of compacted materials that have become entangled, usually evident with grass clippings or leaves. These layers can block airflow, hindering microbial activity.
    • Unpleasant Odors: A healthy compost should have an earthy smell. If your pile starts to emit a sour or rotten scent, it’s a sign that it might be going anaerobic and needs to be aerated.
    • Excessive Moisture: A wet or soggy compost pile can squash beneficial organisms and limit airflow. If you squeeze a handful and water drips out easily, it’s too wet and needs turning.
  • Temperature Monitoring: The compost pile’s internal temperature serves as a gauge for microbial activity. An active compost will feel warm or even hot in the center, showing that decomposition is underway. However, a sudden drop in temperature could indicate a decrease in microbial activity, signaling the need for aeration to rejuvenate the pile. Investing in a compost thermometer can be invaluable for accurate monitoring.
  • Routine Schedule: While observational methods and temperature checks are reactive approaches, setting a regular turning schedule can be proactive. For many gardeners, turning compost every 2-4 weeks proves beneficial. Still, this frequency might vary based on climate, materials used, and the size of the pile.
  • Seasonal Adjustments: The seasons can play a substantial role in your compost’s needs. For instance, during rainy seasons or wetter climates, compost may require more frequent turning to prevent excessive dampness. Conversely, in dry periods, the compost might need moisture addition and less frequent turning.

Armed with this knowledge, gardeners can better gauge when their compost piles need attention, ensuring a more consistent and efficient decomposition process.

Tools for Turning Compost

The tools you use for turning your compost can make a significant difference in the ease and efficiency of the process. The right instrument can mean less physical strain, better aeration, and a more uniformly decomposed compost. Whether you’re a seasoned gardener or a newbie, it’s vital to acquaint yourself with the varied tools available. Here’s a more detailed look at the essential tools for turning compost:

  • Garden Fork or Pitchfork:
    • Description: This is a long-handled tool with sturdy, widely spaced tines, perfect for digging into and lifting compost.
    • Benefits: The design of a garden fork allows you to penetrate deep into the pile, turning the compost effectively. It’s also useful for breaking up clumps and mixing materials.
    • Usage Tips: When using a garden fork, it’s advisable to start from the outer edges of your compost pile, working your way inwards. This ensures the outer, less-decomposed material gets moved to the center, where it heats up and breaks down faster.
  • Compost Aerator:
    • Description: This specialized tool often has a spiral or corkscrew design with a handle on top. Some models come with folding wings or flaps that lift and turn the compost as the tool is pulled up.
    • Benefits: A compost aerator is specifically designed to introduce air deep into the pile without the need for heavy lifting. It’s especially handy for older gardeners or those with back problems.
    • Usage Tips: Push the aerator into the pile until you reach the bottom, then twist and pull upward. This action brings lower compost materials to the top, ensuring a good mix.
  • Compost Tumblers:
    • Description: These are barrel-like containers mounted on a frame, designed to be rotated. Materials are added, and then the tumbler is turned, mixing and aerating the compost inside.
    • Benefits: Compost tumblers are perfect for those who prefer a contained system. They’re often rodent-proof and can produce compost faster due to easy turning and consistent conditions.
    • Usage Tips: Don’t overfill your Tumbler, as this can make it hard to turn. Also, maintain a good balance between green (nitrogen-rich) and brown (carbon-rich) materials for optimal results.
  • Protective Gear:
    • Gloves: Protects your hands from potential irritants in the compost and keep them clean.
    • Mask: Especially useful if you’re sensitive to allergens, a mask can prevent you from inhaling fine compost particles or mold spores.

By investing in the right tools and understanding their proper usage, turning compost becomes a less daunting task, setting you on a smooth path to rich, fertile compost.

Step-by-Step Guide to Turn Compost

Achieving the desired, nutrient-rich compost involves meticulous attention to detail, especially when it comes to turning the compost. This comprehensive step-by-step guide will lead you through the process, ensuring you get the most out of your compost pile.

1. Preparation:

  • Dress appropriately: It’s advisable to wear old clothes as turning compost can be a messy job.
  • Safety First: Put on gloves to protect your hands and, if you’re sensitive, wear a mask to prevent the inhalation of fine particles and allergens.
  • Gather Your Tools: Based on your compost setup, gather the necessary tools such as a garden fork, compost aerator, or a tumbler.

2. Turning with a Garden Fork:

  • Starting Point: Begin at one edge of your compost pile. This approach ensures that you’re moving material from the exterior, which is usually cooler, to the hotter center of the pile.
  • Dig Deep: Insert the garden fork as deeply as you can into the compost. Leveraging the length of the tool helps turn and aerate the bottom layers effectively.
  • Lift and Flip: Pull up the compost using the fork and then flip it over, placing it back into a different spot. This action not only introduces air but ensures materials that were on the outer layers get moved inward.
  • Break Clumps: If you notice large clumps of material, use the fork to break them apart. This improves aeration and ensures more even decomposition.
  • Mix Well: As you turn, aim to mix green (nitrogen-rich) materials with brown (carbon-rich) materials for a balanced compost composition.

Troubleshooting Common Compost Problems

Just like any other gardening endeavor, composting can come with its set of challenges. While turning the compost regularly can prevent many issues, it’s essential to be aware of the common problems and how to address them. Here’s a detailed troubleshooting guide:

1. Unpleasant Odors:

  • Problem: Your compost pile emits a foul, rotten, or ammonia-like smell.
  • Cause: This often results from poor aeration, leading to anaerobic conditions, or from an excess of green (nitrogen-rich) materials.
  • Solution:
    • Ensure regular turning to introduce air and prevent compaction.
    • Balance the compost by adding more brown (carbon-rich) materials, such as leaves, cardboard, or straw, to offset the excess green materials.

2. Slow Decomposition:

  • Problem: The compost isn’t breaking down as quickly as you’d expect.
  • Cause: This can be due to a lack of nitrogen, insufficient moisture, or inadequate aeration.
  • Solution:
    • Add green materials, like fresh grass clippings or manure, to boost nitrogen levels.
    • Moisture is crucial. Your compost should have the consistency of a wrung-out sponge. If it’s too dry, sprinkle some water. If it’s too wet, add more dry brown materials.
    • Turn the compost more frequently to improve aeration.

3. Pests in the Compost:

  • Problem: You’re noticing unwanted guests such as rodents, flies, or other pests in your compost.
  • Cause: They are often attracted to compost piles because of food scraps or due to the compost not heating up enough.
  • Solution:
    • Bury fresh kitchen scraps in the center of the pile, where the heat is greatest.
    • Avoid adding meat, dairy, and oily foods, which can attract pests.
    • Turn the compost regularly to increase its temperature and make it less hospitable for pests.
    • If rodents are an issue, consider using a compost bin with a tight-fitting lid or a mesh base.

4. Too Dry or Too Wet:

  • Problem: The compost is either too dry, resembling loose straw, or too wet, feeling like a soggy mass.
  • Cause: Weather conditions, the type of materials added, or inadequate turning can lead to these moisture imbalances.
  • Solution:
    • For dry compost, add moist green materials or sprinkle water while turning. Ensure it’s uniformly moist, not drenched.
    • For wet compost, add dry brown materials like leaves, cardboard, or sawdust. Turn the pile to integrate these materials and improve aeration.

5. Too Acidic or Alkaline:

  • Problem: The pH level of your compost isn’t optimal, which can affect decomposition and plant health.
  • Cause: Imbalance in the types of materials added or certain stages of decomposition can alter pH.
  • Solution:
    • Test the compost using a pH test kit.
    • If it’s too acidic (low pH), you can add materials like crushed eggshells or a sprinkle of garden lime.
    • If it’s too alkaline (high pH), incorporate materials like pine needles or coffee grounds.

Awareness and swift action are the keys to troubleshooting compost issues. Regularly observing and understanding your compost pile’s behavior ensures that you can spot and rectify problems early on, leading to richer, healthier compost.


Composting is more than just a sustainable waste management practice; it’s an art rooted in understanding the nuanced dance between organic materials, microbes, and environmental conditions. Turning the compost is one of the core rhythms of this dance, ensuring the pile remains aerated, balanced, and full of life.

As we’ve navigated through the importance of turning, its timing, tools, step-by-step guidance, and even troubleshooting common challenges, one element remains consistent: the commitment to nurturing nature’s way of recycling. Whether you’re composting to enrich your garden soil, reduce waste, or both, the process requires patience, attentiveness, and a genuine desire to understand the ecosystem within your compost pile.

Moreover, as every gardener or environmental enthusiast would agree, there’s a profound satisfaction in witnessing food scraps, garden waste, and other organic materials transform into dark, crumbly, nutrient-rich compost. This alchemy not only boosts the health and vitality of your plants but also serves as a testament to the cyclical nature of life.

In embracing composting, you aren’t just turning organic waste; you’re turning the tide towards a more sustainable and harmonious coexistence with our planet. So, as you stand with your garden fork in hand, ready to give your compost another good turn, know that you’re playing a vital role in a process as ancient as life itself, shaping the future one turn at a time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.